Market

Why the houses here look the way they do

What a built out borough on a grid means for what you can buy, what you can change, and what you will pay for.

Haddonfield was built before anyone was drawing cul de sacs. That single fact explains most of what you will see when you start looking at houses here.

Why is the housing so old?

Because the town filled in a long time ago, on a street grid that predates the automobile, and then stopped. Haddonfield incorporated in 1875 and is now 2.80 square miles of land with 4,682 housing units in it at the 2020 Census. The Census counted 4,488 people per square mile. There is not much open ground left to build on.

So the inventory is mostly existing houses on existing lots. Narrow frontages, deep back yards in places, garages that were added later or never existed, and additions built one decade at a time by whoever owned the place then.

What does that mean for what I can buy?

It means your choices are shaped by condition more than by size. Two houses on the same street with the same square footage can sit a hundred thousand dollars apart because one has a new kitchen and the other has 1974 cabinets and a furnace from the Clinton administration.

It also means you are unlikely to find acreage inside the borough line. If a large lot is the requirement, the towns east of here are built for that. If a walk to a downtown and a train is the requirement, this is one of the few places in South Jersey where it is not a compromise.

Does the Historic District limit what I can do?

Yes, if the house is inside it. The district covers 488 houses, buildings and sites, designated locally in 1971 and listed on the state and national registers in the 1980s. Exterior changes, roofing and siding included, need a Certificate of Appropriateness from the Planning Board after design review by the Historic Preservation Commission. Paint color, decorative items and landscaping are not regulated.

That is a real constraint and it is also the reason the town looks the way it does. Buyers who want to change a facade substantially should price the review process into their thinking, which is a conversation to have before the offer rather than after.

Is anything new getting built?

One place, mainly. The Bancroft property has an adopted redevelopment plan, from 2016 and amended in 2018, calling for open space, age targeted housing with an affordable component and preservation of Lullworth Hall. That is the only part of the borough where the map is still being drawn, and it is worth reading the borough's own project pages before you form a view about a house near it.

What do the numbers say about turnover?

Not much moves. At the 2020 Census, 272 of 4,682 units were vacant, about 5.8 percent, and 83.2 percent of occupied homes were owner occupied, per the Census Bureau's 2020 to 2024 estimates. The median value of those owner occupied homes was $755,300 in the same estimate.

A tight, mostly owner occupied borough means fewer listings and less room to be picky. It also means condition and pricing decide how fast a house sells, because the buyers who want this town are not short of reasons to want it.

The market page labels every figure with its source and explains why I will not turn a five year estimate into this week's trend. The neighborhoods page covers where the oldest stock sits.

Wondering what your house would do?

A walkthrough and an honest number, with the reasoning shown. Including when the answer is to wait.

Ask Bob