New Jersey stopped being a colony and started being a state in a tavern on Kings Highway. Most people who drive past 233 Kings Highway East every day have no idea.
Why did the legislature come to Haddonfield?
Because the war pushed it there. The New Jersey State Park Service puts it plainly: military engagements forced the colony's legislators to move the seat of government to a safer haven, and they chose the Indian King Tavern as the place to conduct the affairs of state.
What actually happened in that building?
A fair amount of founding business, in a short window. The General Assembly met there from January 29 to March 18, 1777, and again in May and September of that year. The Declaration of Independence was read into the minutes of the New Jersey Assembly there. The Great Seal of the State of New Jersey was adopted there. The constitution was amended so that official acts of the Governor and the courts ran under the authority of the state rather than the colony.
The Council of Safety, formed to examine people suspected of loyalist activity, was organized at the tavern and held its first meeting there in March 1777. Twenty war measures came out of that room, from purchasing arms to exempting defense workers from militia duty.
How old is the building?
Older than the legislature that met in it, and built in stages. The New Jersey Historic Trust describes a frame house constructed about 1732, a three story brick structure added in 1741 with a kitchen wing and a paved cellar, and a brick extension added around 1764. The legislature met in the 1741 section.
It became a tavern in 1777 when Hugh Creighton bought the buildings and converted them, and the name came with him from an earlier tavern across the highway.
What happened to it afterward?
It kept changing hands and uses, spent time as a hotel, and by 1903 it was a building the state decided to save. New Jersey acquired the Indian King Tavern on June 15, 1903, removed later additions and restored the original layout. That made it the first property the state preserved as a museum, which is why people call it New Jersey's first state owned historic site.
It is still a state historic site. The first and second floors are open to the public, and the room where the Assembly sat is the reason to go.
Should I visit?
Yes, and check the hours before you do. Hours are published by the New Jersey State Park Service and they are not the same in every season, so the state page is the one to trust rather than a blog post, including this one. The address is 233 Kings Highway East, in the middle of everything.
If you are buying in the Historic District, this building is also the best argument for the rules you will be asked to follow. The reason the street looks like this is that the town stopped treating old buildings as temporary a long time ago. The neighborhoods page explains what those rules mean for an owner.
Buying in the Historic District?
Ask me what a Certificate of Appropriateness covers before you plan a project.